Casey's Choice - Page 1 - Casey at Bat Collectibles

ACCOUNT

CART

Showing 143 results for

Compare Add to Cart The item has been added

Unique Mickey Mantle Joe DiMaggio Ted Williams Signed OAL Harridge Baseball JSA

MSRP:

Was:

Now: $8,999.00
Compare Add to Cart The item has been added

Red Ruffing Single Signed Official American League Baseball Very Rare! JSA LOA

MSRP:

Was:

Now: $4,500.00
Compare Add to Cart The item has been added

Chuck Dressen Single Signed Official National League Frick Baseball 1930s JSA

MSRP:

Was:

Now: $3,150.00
Compare Add to Cart The item has been added

Connie Mack Single Signed Reach Official League Baseball PSA LOA

MSRP:

Was:

Now: $2,699.00
Compare Add to Cart The item has been added

Max Carey Single Signed Official American League Baseball JSA/BAS LOAs

MSRP:

Was:

Now: $7,999.00
Compare Add to Cart The item has been added

Joe Cronin Single Signed Official American League Baseball JSA LOA

MSRP:

Was:

Now: $2,699.00
Compare Add to Cart The item has been added

Lefty Grove Single Signed Baseball RARE PSA/BAS LOAs

MSRP:

Was:

Now: $4,499.00
Compare Add to Cart The item has been added

Bart Giamatti Signed Official National League Baseball BAS LOA

MSRP:

Was:

Now: $1,350.00
Compare Add to Cart The item has been added

Ted Kluszewski Single Signed Baseball MINT CONDITION! BAS LOA

MSRP:

Was:

Now: $1,079.00
Compare Add to Cart The item has been added

1956 Indianapolis Indians Signed Baseball w/ Minor League Roger Maris Auto! BAS

MSRP:

Was:

Now: $2,250.00
Compare Add to Cart The item has been added

MINT Roger Maris Single Signed Baseball w/Original Box Super Bold & Clean! BAS

MSRP:

Was:

Now: $8,999.00
Compare Add to Cart The item has been added

The Finest Mickey Mantle HOF 1974 Signed Baseball PSA/BAS Graded GEM MINT 10!

MSRP:

Was:

Now: $6,299.00
Compare Add to Cart The item has been added

UDA Mickey Mantle NO.7 Signed OAL Baseball Super Nice! Upper Deck Box Bag COA

MSRP:

Was:

Now: $2,150.00
Compare Add to Cart The item has been added

Theodore Samuel Williams Full Name Signed OAL Baseball Very Clean! PSA/JSA LOAs

MSRP:

Was:

Now: $3,150.00
Compare Add to Cart The item has been added

Sandy Koufax PG 9/9/65 Signed Official Major League Baseball Super Bold! PSA LOA

MSRP:

Was:

Now: $1,699.00
Compare Add to Cart The item has been added

President Gerald Ford Signed Autographed OAL Baseball 38th US President JSA LOA

MSRP:

Was:

Now: $719.00
Compare Add to Cart The item has been added

Mickey Mantle NO.7 Signed Louisville Slugger K55 Game Model Bat JSA Holo Grade 8

MSRP:

Was:

Now: $5,399.00
Compare Add to Cart The item has been added

Sandy Koufax Cy 63 65 66 Signed Mitchell & Ness White Dodgers Jersey JSA LOA

MSRP:

Was:

Now: $3,599.00
Compare Add to Cart The item has been added

Sandy Koufax Signed Mitchell & Ness White Dodgers Jersey JSA LOA

MSRP:

Was:

Now: $2,249.00
Compare Add to Cart The item has been added

Shohei Ohtani Signed Authentic Angels Jersey Rookie Era Auto MINT! MLB Hologram

MSRP:

Was:

Now: $9,999.00
Compare Add to Cart The item has been added

Mel Ott Signed Albertype HOF Plaque Postcard EX 5 Auto Grade 8 (POP 1 of 1)

MSRP:

Was:

Now: $3,999.00
Compare Add to Cart The item has been added

AC Dazzy Vance Signed 3x5 Index Card PSA Graded MINT 9!

MSRP:

Was:

Now: $809.00
Compare Add to Cart The item has been added

Frank Baker Full Name Signed 3x5 Index Card PSA Graded NM-MT 8

MSRP:

Was:

Now: $809.00
Compare Add to Cart The item has been added

Mickey Mantle 1956 Triple Crown Signed OAL Baseball Gorgeous! JSA LOA

MSRP:

Was:

Now: $3,150.00
Compare Add to Cart The item has been added

Ted Williams Signed Official American League Baseball JSA LOA Graded MINT 9

MSRP:

Was:

Now: $899.00
Compare Add to Cart The item has been added

Jim Catfish Hunter Vintage 1970s Signed Official American League Baseball PSA

MSRP:

Was:

Now: $899.00
Compare Add to Cart The item has been added

Frank Thoman 35 Rookie Era Signed Official American League Baseball JSA COA

MSRP:

Was:

Now: $1,169.00
Compare Add to Cart The item has been added

Vintage Yogi Berra Signed Official American League Cronin Baseball JSA COA

MSRP:

Was:

Now: $899.00
Compare Add to Cart The item has been added

Carl Hubbell Signed Official National League Baseball JSA LOA

MSRP:

Was:

Now: $449.00
Compare Add to Cart The item has been added

Pete Rose HOF ?? Signed Official Major League Baseball MINT! PSA COA

MSRP:

Was:

Now: $899.00
Compare Add to Cart The item has been added

Tom Glavine Full Name Heavily Inscribed Official Major League Baseball Leaf COA

MSRP:

Was:

Now: $449.00
Compare Add to Cart The item has been added

Al Lopez HOF 77 Signed Official American League Baseball JSA COA #CG54022

MSRP:

Was:

Now: $459.00
Compare Add to Cart The item has been added

Mike Schmidt HOF 95 Signed HOF Logo Official Major League Baseball MLB Holo

MSRP:

Was:

Now: $225.00
Compare Add to Cart The item has been added

Chipper Jones HOF 18 Signed HOF Logo Official Major League Baseball Fanatics

MSRP:

Was:

Now: $225.00
Compare Add to Cart The item has been added

Stan Musial HOF 69 Signed Official Major League Baseball JSA COA #V11171

MSRP:

Was:

Now: $269.00
Compare Add to Cart The item has been added

Shohei Ohtani Signed Official Major League Baseball MLB Holo/BAS Encapsulated

MSRP:

Was:

Now: $10,799.00
Compare Add to Cart The item has been added

Shohei Ohtani Signed Official Major League Baseball MLB Holo/PSA Graded MINT 9!

MSRP:

Was:

Now: $13,499.00
Compare Add to Cart The item has been added

Yogi Berra Signed 2X It Ain't Over Till It's Yogi Berra Signed OAL Baseball JSA

MSRP:

Was:

Now: $1,349.00
Compare Add to Cart The item has been added

Lawrence Yogi Berra MVP 51 54 55 STAT Signed OAL Baseball JSA COA

MSRP:

Was:

Now: $1,349.00
Compare Add to Cart The item has been added

MINT Shohei Ohtani #17 Signed Official Major League Baseball PSA LOA

MSRP:

Was:

Now: $8,999.00
Compare Add to Cart The item has been added

Shohei Ohtani #17 Signed Official Major League Baseball Super Clean! JSA LOA

MSRP:

Was:

Now: $8,099.00
Compare Add to Cart The item has been added

Shohei Ohtani Signed 2021 All Star Logo Official Baseball MLB/Fanatics Holos

MSRP:

Was:

Now: $7,199.00
Compare Add to Cart The item has been added

Chas Gehringer AL MVP 1937 Signed Official American League Baseball JSA COA

MSRP:

Was:

Now: $899.00
Compare Add to Cart The item has been added

George Lou Brett Signed Official American League Baseball JSA COA #CI52635

MSRP:

Was:

Now: $539.00
Compare Add to Cart The item has been added

Willie Stargell HOF 88 1979 MVP Signed ONL Baseball JSA COA #CI52637

MSRP:

Was:

Now: $585.00
Compare Add to Cart The item has been added

1990s Michael Jordan Signed Red Champion Swingman Chicago Bulls Jersey UDA Holo

MSRP:

Was:

Now: $8,999.00
Compare Add to Cart The item has been added

Barry Bonds Signed Official National League Baseball Clean! JSA COA #CI52628

MSRP:

Was:

Now: $359.00
Compare Add to Cart The item has been added

Michael Jordan Signed 16x20 Photograph 1988 Gatorade Free Throw Dunk UDA COA

MSRP:

Was:

Now: $6,299.00
Compare Add to Cart The item has been added

Michael Jordan HOF 2009 Signed Spalding Basketball LE #18/123 UDA Upper Deck

MSRP:

Was:

Now: $13,500.00
Compare Add to Cart The item has been added

Michael Jordan Signed Nike North Carolina Tar Heels Jersey UDA Upper Deck PSA

MSRP:

Was:

Now: $8,999.00
Compare Add to Cart The item has been added

Unique Mickey Mantle Rookie 1951 Signed 8x10 Photo Extremely Rare Image! JSA LOA

MSRP:

Was:

Now: $1,799.00
Compare Add to Cart The item has been added

Mickey Mantle Signed Hillerich & Bradsby Game Model Bat Pristine Condition! BAS

MSRP:

Was:

Now: $3,999.00
Compare Add to Cart The item has been added

Tom Brady & David Ortiz Signed 11x14 Photograph Framed MLB Tristar & Fanatics

MSRP:

Was:

Now: $1,999.00
Compare Add to Cart The item has been added

Mel Ott Signed 3x5 Index Card PSA/DNA Graded Mint 9!!!

MSRP:

Was:

Now: $1,349.00
Compare Add to Cart The item has been added

Tom Seaver 311 W's HOF 92 Signed ONL Baseball JSA COA

MSRP:

Was:

Now: $499.00
Compare Add to Cart The item has been added

Joe DiMaggio HOF 55 Signed Official American League Baseball JSA LOA

MSRP:

Was:

Now: $1,450.00
Compare Add to Cart The item has been added

Spectacular Mickey Mantle Signed OAL Baseball Clean! JSA LOA Graded MINT 9

MSRP:

Was:

Now: $1,599.00
Compare Add to Cart The item has been added

Charlie Gehringer Mechanical Man Signed Official American League Baseball JSA

MSRP:

Was:

Now: $449.00
Compare Add to Cart The item has been added

Bill Summers "1955" Signed Official American League Harridge Baseball JSA LOA

MSRP:

Was:

Now: $899.00
Compare Add to Cart The item has been added

HUGE Ted Williams Signed 20x24 Photograph Military Air Force JSA LOA #ZZ18856

MSRP:

Was:

Now: $1,349.00
Compare Add to Cart The item has been added

HUGE Ted Williams Signed 20x24 Photograph Military Air Force JSA LOA #ZZ18858

MSRP:

Was:

Now: $1,349.00
Compare Add to Cart The item has been added

Larry Yogi Berra Yankees 46-63 Signed OAL Baseball JSA COA #CB09145

MSRP:

Was:

Now: $639.00
Compare Add to Cart The item has been added

Yogi Berra MVP 51 54 57 Signed OML Baseball Clean! JSA COA #CB09141

MSRP:

Was:

Now: $449.00
Compare Add to Cart The item has been added

Harmon Killebrew NO. 3 Signed Official Major League Baseball JSA COA #CB09166

MSRP:

Was:

Now: $249.00
Compare Add to Cart The item has been added

The Finest Pepper Martin Single Signed Baseball 1931 Gas House Gang Hero PSA LOA

MSRP:

Was:

Now: $6,750.00
Compare Add to Cart The item has been added

Bill Veeck Single Signed Official American League Baseball RARE! PSA/DNA LOA

MSRP:

Was:

Now: $4,500.00
Compare Add to Cart The item has been added

Bill Veeck Single Signed Official American League Baseball RARE! JSA LOA

MSRP:

Was:

Now: $3,150.00
Compare Add to Cart The item has been added

Dizzy Dean Single Signed Official National League Baseball JSA LOA

MSRP:

Was:

Now: $2,250.00
Compare Add to Cart The item has been added

Jack Warhop Single Signed Baseball Babe Ruth's First Home Run Victim! BAS LOA

MSRP:

Was:

Now: $5,500.00
Compare Add to Cart The item has been added

Myril Hoag Single Signed OAL Harridge Baseball 1/1 Exceedingly RARE! BAS LOA

MSRP:

Was:

Now: $4,499.00
Compare Add to Cart The item has been added

The Finest George Selkirk Single Signed OAL Baseball Exceedingly RARE! JSA LOA

MSRP:

Was:

Now: $1,799.00
Compare Add to Cart The item has been added

1953 NY Yankees WS Champs Signed Baseball (28 sigs) Mickey Mantle PSA/BAS LOAs

MSRP:

Was:

Now: $3,599.00
Compare Add to Cart The item has been added

1953 Yankees WS Champs Signed Baseball (28 sigs) Mickey Mantle PSA/BAS LOAs

MSRP:

Was:

Now: $2,699.00
Compare Add to Cart The item has been added

1955 Yankees Team Signed Baseball Mickey Mantle Casey Stengel PSA/DNA Graded 8!

MSRP:

Was:

Now: $4,999.00
Compare Add to Cart The item has been added

Jesse Tannehill William Dummy Hoy Dead Ball Era Multi Signed Baseball JSA

MSRP:

Was:

Now: $4,500.00
Compare Add to Cart The item has been added

Sandy Koufax HOF 72 Signed Official National League Baseball PSA/DNA Holo

MSRP:

Was:

Now: $1,449.00
Compare Add to Cart The item has been added

Willie Mays 660 HR Signed Official National League Baseball RARE! PSA/DNA COA

MSRP:

Was:

Now: $2,699.00
Compare Add to Cart The item has been added

Joe DiMaggio HOF 55 Signed Official American League Baseball Nice! PSA/DNA COA

MSRP:

Was:

Now: $1,450.00
Compare Add to Cart The item has been added

Joe DiMaggio 361 HR's Signed Official American League Logo Baseball JSA LOA

MSRP:

Was:

Now: $1,799.00
Compare Add to Cart The item has been added

Mickey Mantle Signed Official American League Baseball PSA Auto Grade MINT 9!

MSRP:

Was:

Now: $1,799.00
Compare Add to Cart The item has been added

RARE Bryce Harper 12 NL ROY Official Major League Baseball MLB/Fanatics Holos

MSRP:

Was:

Now: $825.00
Compare Add to Cart The item has been added

Carl Yastrzemski TC 67 Signed Major League Baseball MLB/Fanatics Holos

MSRP:

Was:

Now: $275.00
Compare Add to Cart The item has been added

The Finest Roger Maris Signed 8X10 Photograph BAS LOA Graded GEM MINT 10!!!

MSRP:

Was:

Now: $1,550.00
Compare Add to Cart The item has been added

Vintage Willie Mays Signed Spalding Official National League Baseball JSA LOA

MSRP:

Was:

Now: $1,799.00
Compare Add to Cart The item has been added

Willie Mays #24 Signed Official Major League Baseball JSA Sticker #YY77367

MSRP:

Was:

Now: $899.00
Compare Add to Cart The item has been added

Hank Aaron Home Run King Signed ONL Baseball JSA LOA Graded MINT 9!

MSRP:

Was:

Now: $1,799.00
Compare Add to Cart The item has been added

Roger Maris Single Signed Official American League Baseball PSA/DNA Graded 8

MSRP:

Was:

Now: $8,999.00
Compare Add to Cart The item has been added

1920s Rabbit Maranville Single Signed Official National League Baseball PSA LOA

MSRP:

Was:

Now: $8,999.00
Compare Add to Cart The item has been added

Roger Maris Single Signed Baseball Circa 1961 PSA/DNA Graded 7

MSRP:

Was:

Now: $4,499.00
Compare Add to Cart The item has been added

Ted Theodore Samuel Williams Signed OAL Baseball Amazing! PSA/DNA Graded 8

MSRP:

Was:

Now: $2,899.00
Compare Add to Cart The item has been added

Derek Jeter 00 WS MVP Signed OML Baseball Steiner Holo

MSRP:

Was:

Now: $899.00
Compare Add to Cart The item has been added

Highest Graded Willie Mays Signed ONL Baseball PSA/DNA Graded GEM MINT 10!!!

MSRP:

Was:

Now: $899.00
Compare Add to Cart The item has been added

Willie Mays “The Catch” HOF 79 Signed 16x20 Photograph Super Rare! JSA LOA

MSRP:

Was:

Now: $3,599.00
Compare Add to Cart The item has been added

Paul Daffy Dean Single Signed Baseball - Super Rare! PSA/DNA Graded 9

MSRP:

Was:

Now: $3,250.00
Compare Add to Cart The item has been added

Willie Mays Hank Aaron Stan Musial Total Bases Signed ONL Baseball JSA LOA

MSRP:

Was:

Now: $1,619.00
Compare Add to Cart The item has been added

Unique Yogi Berra HOF 72 My Greatest Thrill #8 Signed OML Baseball JSA LOA

MSRP:

Was:

Now: $675.00